How do you match only valid roman numerals with a regular expression?
Thinking about my other problem, i decided I can't even create a regular expression that will match roman numerals (let alone a context-free grammar that will generate them)
The problem is matching only valid roman numerals. Eg, 990 is NOT "XM", it's "CMXC"
My problem in making the regex for this is that in order to allow or not allow certain characters, I need to look back. Let's take thousands and hundreds, for example.
I can allow M{0,2}C?M (to allow for 900, 1000, 1900, 2000, 2900 and 3000). However, If the match is on CM, I can't allow following characters to be C or D (because I'm already at 900).
How can I express this in a regex?
If it's simply not expressible in a regex, is it expressible in a context-free grammar?
Try:
^M{0,4}(CM|CD|D?C{0,3})(XC|XL|L?X{0,3})(IX|IV|V?I{0,3})$
Breaking it down:
M{0,4}
This specifies the thousands section and basically restrains it to between 0 and 4000 . It's a relatively simple:
0: <empty> matched by M{0}
1000: M matched by M{1}
2000: MM matched by M{2}
3000: MMM matched by M{3}
4000: MMMM matched by M{4}
(CM|CD|D?C{0,3})
Slightly more complex, this is for the hundreds section and covers all the possibilities:
0: <empty> matched by D?C{0} (with D not there)
100: C matched by D?C{1} (with D not there)
200: CC matched by D?C{2} (with D not there)
300: CCC matched by D?C{3} (with D not there)
400: CD matched by CD
500: D matched by D?C{0} (with D there)
600: DC matched by D?C{1} (with D there)
700: DCC matched by D?C{2} (with D there)
800: DCCC matched by D?C{3} (with D there)
900: CM matched by CM
(XC|XL|L?X{0,3})
Same rules as previous section but for the tens place:
0: <empty> matched by L?X{0} (with L not there)
10: X matched by L?X{1} (with L not there)
20: XX matched by L?X{2} (with L not there)
30: XXX matched by L?X{3} (with L not there)
40: XL matched by XL
50: L matched by L?X{0} (with L there)
60: LX matched by L?X{1} (with L there)
70: LXX matched by L?X{2} (with L there)
80: LXXX matched by L?X{3} (with L there)
90: XC matched by XC
(IX|IV|V?I{0,3})
This is the units section, handling 0 through 9 and also similar to the previous two sections (Roman numerals, despite their seeming weirdness, follow some logical rules once you figure out what they are):
0: <empty> matched by V?I{0} (with V not there)
1: I matched by V?I{1} (with V not there)
2: II matched by V?I{2} (with V not there)
3: III matched by V?I{3} (with V not there)
4: IV matched by IV
5: V matched by V?I{0} (with V there)
6: VI matched by V?I{1} (with V there)
7: VII matched by V?I{2} (with V there)
8: VIII matched by V?I{3} (with V there)
9: IX matched by IX
Actually, your premise is flawed. 990 IS "XM", as well as "CMXC".
The Romans were far less concerned about the "rules" than your third grade teacher. As long as it added up, it was OK. Hence "IIII" was just as good as "IV" for 4. And "IIM" was completely cool for 998.
(If you have trouble dealing with that... Remember English spellings were not formalized until the 1700s. Until then, as long as the reader could figure it out, it was good enough).
To avoid matching the empty string you'll need to repeat the pattern four times and replace each 0 with a 1 in turn, and account for V , L and D :
(M{1,4}(CM|CD|D?C{0,3})(XC|XL|L?X{0,3})(IX|IV|V?I{0,3})|M{0,4}(CM|C?D|D?C{1,3})(XC|XL|L?X{0,3})(IX|IV|V?I{0,3})|M{0,4}(CM|CD|D?C{0,3})(XC|X?L|L?X{1,3})(IX|IV|V?I{0,3})|M{0,4}(CM|CD|D?C{0,3})(XC|XL|L?X{0,3})(IX|I?V|V?I{1,3}))
In this case (because this pattern uses ^ and $ ) you would be better off checking for empty lines first and don't bother matching them. If you are using word boundaries then you don't have a problem because there's no such thing as an empty word. (At least regex doesn't define one; don't start philosophising, I'm being pragmatic here!)
In my own particular (real world) case I needed match numerals at word endings and I found no other way around it. I needed to scrub off the footnote numbers from my plain text document, where text such as "the Red Seacl and the Great Barrier Reefcli" had been converted to the Red Seacl and the Great Barrier Reefcli . But I still had problems with valid words like Tahiti and fantastic are scrubbed into Tahit and fantasti .
上一篇: 如何使用正则表达式提取子字符串
下一篇: 你如何只用正则表达式匹配有效的罗马数字？